03-10-2009, 09:03 PM
Kara Wrote:Quote:OK, here's a suggestion: you don't have the intrinsic right to answer a post which took hours to research with a one-liner. That would be a good start.
I'm assuming, then, that the following "one-liners" are acceptable on this forum:
"i think you're being humble -- aren't the ramifications of this HUGE for pushing Peshitta primacy? i was reading it with jaw hanging open..."
"Greek primacy is finished...however one must take to heart the words of Max Planck."
"This is fascinating!"
Etc.
C'mon, Paul. Now, all of a sudden, there are rules behind one-liners? Is it or is that not a double standard? Yes or no and why. No sidestepping.
.
Well I am responsible for the one liner I have emboldened. I have been studying these things and posting on forums at peshitta.org since 2001 IIRC.
After 8 years I have never seen any serious refutation of the material posted here. So my "one liner" is really in response to more than just this one post.
But here is a question for you.
If you think the peshitta was edited to conform to the hymnal then what you proposing Aramaic speaking believers were using prior to this in their NT?