Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Matthew 22:43
'He said to them, "How then did Dawid in the spirit call him Master YHWH? For he said..."- Matthew 22:43, AENT

'He said to them, "Yet how does Dawid spiritually call him Marya? For he said..."- Aramaic Peshitta New Testament Translation: Messianic Version

"He words to them, How, in spirit, calls David him Lord for he words..."- Aramaic New Covenant

I am referring to the part translated variously as "in the spirit", "spiritually", and "in spirit". It is "b'rukh". Janet Magiera gives the clearest translation of that phrase, but Herb Jahn gives the most literal. "In the Spirit" in Aramaic would be "b'Rukha". Mark and Luke both say "b'Rukha d'Qudsha". I think you put these two together, it would be, "Yet how does Dawid spiritually [moved] by the Rukha d'Qudsha call Him MarYa?"

Why does everyone else translate "b'rukh" as "by the Spirit" in that verse. There is no definite article. This seems to be speaking of David being spiritually moved by the Holy Spirit. Jesus' point (that David was moved by the Spirit of God to call the Messiah the Lord Yahweh) is conveyed accurately by translating it as "by the Spirit", but it is more accurately (when speaking of only Matthew's wording) rendered as "spiritually". This is my opinion, but I am fine with being wrong! <!-- sSmile --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/smile.gif" alt="Smile" title="Smile" /><!-- sSmile -->
I think it would be best to render it "by The Spirit"

"Rukha d'Qudsha" in the parrallel pasages = by The Spirit of Holiness" not "by The Holy Spirit" as to the actual wording...but, we know that "The Spirit of Holiness" is the same as "The Holy Spirit", when we read Acts 13:2 in the Aramaic text, so, it's not just any "spirit", but "The Spirit of God" it's speaking of, which inspired David.

Dylan, I'm not sure where we would get "spiritually moved" from the text itself. It is implied though. "David, [spiritually moved] by The Spirit" would be ok I guess, to help make the sense better in English. But it might be better without it.
In the EPNT Anglicized Version I am using "The Spirit of Holiness", like Etheridge. I love that literal translation <!-- sSmile --><img src="{SMILIES_PATH}/smile.gif" alt="Smile" title="Smile" /><!-- sSmile --> Thanks for your input! What I means was in Matthew 22:43, put it as "Yet how does Dawid, spiritually [moved], call Him 'MarYa'?"

Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)